Roof Repair vs. Roof Replacement: Which One Do I Need?

Roofs are built to last, but years of harsh weather will wear them down. From hail and high-speed winds during spring and summer thunderstorms to snow accumulation and ice dam formation during winter, your roof bears the brunt of punishment from the elements.


When homeowners in Minnesota discover damage to their roof, they’re left with a choice: whether to repair the damage or to completely replace the roof. Continue reading to learn whether your specific situation calls for roof repairs or roof replacement.

How to Determine If You Need Roof Repair or Roof Replacement

  • Age of the Roof – One of the main determining factors in whether roof repair or replacement is needed is how old your roof is. If you’ve had a roof installed on your home in Minnesota within the past decade, you’re better off making repairs. While a roof’s average lifespan will vary based on the materials used, any roof should last a minimum of 12 years and, with proper care, most will last for 30 or more. However, if your roof is over 20 years old, you may be better off having it replaced with a brand new roof.
step-3
  • Extent of the Damage – The most important factor to consider when choosing between roof repair and roof replacement is how widespread and severe the damage is. Does your roof have a few missing shingles and a minor leak contained to one area? Roof repairs will probably be sufficient to restore your roof to optimal condition. Does your roof have extensive damage across multiple areas? Then you’ll most likely need a full roof replacement.

  • The Cost – Roof replacement in Minnesota is much more expensive than roof repairs. On average, roof repairs can be completed for less than $500; roof replacement usually costs $5,000 or more, depending on the size of the roof and the materials used. Whether or not a full roof replacement is worth it to you may ultimately be the deciding factor between repair and replacement. If you’re going to be living in your home for another decade or more, roof replacement might be a better investment than making repairs every couple years. But if you’re planning to sell your home in the next few years, a roof replacement might just not be worth it.

Trusted Roof Repair & Replacement Contractors in MN

Whether you decide to have your roof repaired or replaced, it’s important to choose an experienced team of roofers for the job. Contact Incline Exteriors today if you’d like to schedule roof repair or replacement services in the greater Lake Minnetonka area!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *